Woman Refuses Treatment Saying She's Already Dead & Moves Doctor
July 25, 2017

Marco DePlano is a urologist in Italy. It took years of schooling to get him where he is. And yet, his greatest lesson didn't come from a textbook or a medical conference. He says it came from an elderly patient refusing treatment because she was already dead.
It surprised Marco DePlano when his 80-year-old patient refused the treatment he offered. But her explanation of why moved him to tears. Newsner reports that the urologist shared the encounter on his Facebook page.
Marco wrote:
“Today I received a call to do a consultation in another department. The usual… It was about a patient with terminal cancer and renal insufficiency due to compression of the ureters. The woman I met there was between 70 and 80, with carrot-orange hair and flawless pink fingernail polish.
- Good morning, Ma’am.
- Good morning to you, Doctor.
I looked in her file, did an examination, and repeated the ultrasound.
- Ma’am, your kidneys are struggling: they can’t eliminate urine naturally anymore, so I will need to insert a tube, a kind of valve that bypasses the obstacles. So then you’ll pee into two tubes connected to two bags…
- Excuse me, Dr. That means I’ll have another pouch behind me too?
(She'd already had a colostomy.)
- Yes, Ma’am.
There was a long silence. It felt endless. But then at last, she looked up at me smiling.
RELATED: Parents Hear Of Deadly Threat, Then Learn It May Cost Their Son's Life To Stop It
- Sorry, what’s your name?
- Deplano.
- No, your name.
- Marco.
- Marco… what a beautiful name. Do you have a moment?
- Of course, Ma’am.
- You know, I’m already dead. You understand?
- Sorry, no… I don’t.
- I already died 15 years ago. When my 33-year-old son had a heart attack and passed away. I died that day too.
- I’m so sorry.
Facing Death Without Fear
Credit: ©Thinkstock/KenDrysdale- I died then, with him. And then I died again ten years ago when they diagnosed me with this disease. But now I don’t have to pretend anymore. My children are taken care of, grandchildren too. I want to go join him. What’s the point in living a few extra days with these bags, with suffering and so much work for me and my loved ones? I have my dignity. Will you be offended if I don’t want to do anything? I’m tired. I’m ready to entrust myself to the hands of God. Tell me the truth, will I suffer?
- No, Ma’am. You can do whatever you want. But putting two bags…
- Marco, I said no. It’s my life. I’ve decided. If you want something to do, let’s stop the transfusion. Then I can go home and eat ice cream with my grandson.
Every word she said stripped away my defenses, as if taking petals off a flower. I forgot my exhaustion, my anger and frustration, everything. I forgot the years of study, the thousands of pages I’d read, the rules, the facts. I felt naked and disarmed facing this candor, this awareness of death.
RELATED: A Prayer For Those Who Are Waiting On Healing
I turned around to write in the file so the nurse wouldn’t see the tears in my eyes. I was so moved. Anyone who knows me knows that’s not usually me.
- Marco, does this touch you?
- Yes, a bit, Ma’am. I’m sorry.
- No, it’s nice. Thank you. It makes me feel important. Listen, please do me one other favor. If my children come and shout at you, call me. I’ll tell them to stop. Write that I’m okay. Okay?
- Yes, Ma’am.
- Marco, can I ask you something else?
- Sure!
- You’re special. I know you’ll go far. Give me a kiss, like you would if you were my son — do you mind?
- Of course not.
- I’ll pray for you. And for my son. I hope to see you again.
- Me too. Thank you, Ma’am.
In that moment she was the most beautiful person in the world: radiant, confident, mother, grandmother — pure love.
She gave me the greatest lesson of my life, with those simple words. Death is the final part of life. There’s no need for fear, anxiety, or selfishness. Things that years of study don’t teach you. I felt so small there, in front of this magnitude.
Suffering is part of love, it brings people together sometimes even more than love itself. And sometimes a kind word is a more powerful cure than the most modern drug. Whatever you think, cherish the journey.”
Already Dead
The secret to this woman's beauty was her faith. It's what allowed her to love like she did. And it's what allowed her to face death without fear.
Jesus made it clear our time on earth is temporary. So, in a way, we are all already dead. But it's not a cause to mourn, but rather to rejoice. It means the pain and suffering we experience in our lives is temporary. And as Christians, we know that what waits for us on the other side of earthly death is far better than anything we can imagine here on earth!
"Jesus said to her, I am the resurrection, and the life: he that believes in me, though he were dead, yet shall he live:" John 11:25
h/t: Newsner
Featured Image Credit: ©Thinkstock/ipopba
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: Grandma Snaps A Stranger’s Picture, Then Learns Why God Had Her Do It
Today's Devotional
A Prayer When You Need God to Fight for You - Your Daily Prayer - April 14
God doesn’t just offer to help us fight. He owns the battle entirely. He doesn’t need our strategy or our strength. He asks for our stillness and our trust.
Today's Devotional
A Prayer When You Need God to Fight for You - Your Daily Prayer - April 14
God doesn’t just offer to help us fight. He owns the battle entirely. He doesn’t need our strategy or our strength. He asks for our stillness and our trust.
Past Stories
- Brave Teenager Saves Her 42-Year-Old Mother After Sudden Heart Attack
- This Hallmark Commercial for Mother's Day Sums Up Motherhood In 1 Tear-Jerking Video
- Our Fallen Heroes Are Honored With A Memorial Day Tribute Of 'Amazing Grace' On The Bagpipes
- Coffey Anderson's Patriotic Song 'Memorial Day' Pays Tribute to the Price Fallen Heroes Pay for Us
- Assistant Manager at a Grocery Store Stops a Scam and Saves a Couple From Losing a Lot of Money
- Family Honors Veteran’s Life of Hard Work by Donating His Liver at Age 100
- How I Saw God at the Masters 2026 Tournament
- Texas Family Overjoyed After Dog Who Was Missing For 2 Years Turns Up at New Jersey Mall
- Wife Uses a Phone App to Find Her Husband That Was Buried By An Avalanche
- Comedian Anita Renfro with 'The Mom Song' to the William Tell Overture Is a Mother's Day Classic
- 10 Christian Songs To Motivate Your Workout and Get You Moving This Spring
- Doctor Goes Beyond to Adopt Boy Who Arrived Alone for Surgery and Find Homes for His Siblings
- Simple Facebook Post Turns an Empty Birthday Party Into a Viral Celebration for a 9-Year-Old Girl
- Survivors of the New York Runway Accident Share Their Stories of Survival and Bravery
- Mom Is Overcome as Her Entire Family Signs Happy Birthday to Her Deaf Son
- Woman Dies a Hero After Shielding Grandson From Oncoming Car
- 9-Year-Old With a Big Heart Creates Autism Emergency Kits for First Responders
- Married Since 1951: Their 75-Year Secret to Lasting Love
- The Waiting Season Isn't Wasted
- After Losing His Girlfriend in a DUI Crash, Young Man Opens Coffee Shop to Honor Her Memory
- Boy Heartbroken Over Lost Pokémon Collection Gets 15,000 Cards From Airline Staff
- After Losing His 10-Year-Old Son to Cancer, Dad Runs 240 Miles to Give Back to Other Families
- Abandoned Airport Dog Finds Forever Home With the Officer Who Rescued Him
- After Calling 911 to Help Save Her Father’s Life, Young Girl is Being Honored By Her Community
- High School Team Makes Time for Fourth Graders Who Became Their Loudest Fans
- Bride Honors Her Dad in the Most Beautiful Way Before Their Father-Daughter Dance
- From College Romance to Friendship — and Back Again After One Life-Changing Moment
- 12 Great Christian Songs About Following Jesus
- 10 Christian Baby Dedication Songs
- 12 Amazing Granny Pod Ideas For The Backyard
- 20 Best Birthday Bible Verses for Women | Encourage with Scripture
- North Texas Father Finds Comfort in Newborn Son After Wife Dies in Childbirth
- High School Students Form Special Bond With Seniors Through Chair Volleyball Games
- Top 20 Hymns for Church: Christian Songs for Worship
- Faith, Speed and the Power of a Pit Crew
- 12 Years After His Death, Officers Honor Fallen Colleague by Standing With His Daughter on Her Wedding Day
- 3 Siblings Became Accidental Viral Stars and Now, Their Covers Are Inspiring Faith
- 20 Female Christian Artists Shaping Christian Music Today
- Dog Crashes the 2026 Winter Olympics Cross-Country Race and Sprints to the Finish Line
- Construction Crew Lifts Spirits of Girl Awaiting Heart Transplant in the Sweetest Way
- He Delivered Mail for 33 Years, Then the Community Delivered Love Right Back
- These First Graders Designed Their Own Winter Hats, and Now They’re Wearing Them
- When an 8-Month-Old’s Stroller Blew Into a Lake, One Man Didn’t Hesitate and Went in to Save Her
- On Random Acts of Kindness Day, Florist Leaves Flowers Around the City for Strangers to Find
- Is The Resurrection A Myth? Here's The Truth About Why We Celebrate Easter
- 26-Year-Old Swept Out to Sea, Then His Friend’s Quick Thinking Changed Everything
- Twins Have Daughters On the Very Same Day, 'The Greatest Thing We Could Have Been Given'
- The God of Detail
- Heartbroken Parents Take 2-Year-Old Off Life Support And Then Get An Easter Miracle
- Singer Shares A New Take On The Resurrection From This Hillsong Hit
Top Artists
Top Music Videos

We The Kingdom We The Kingdom Inspire and Uplift with ‘Don’t Let The Darkness’

Alabama Live Performance of 'Because He Lives' by Alabama

Chris Tomlin Chris Tomlin’s Powerful Live Rendition of ‘The First Hymn’ Will Stir Your Soul

John Mark McMillan John Mark McMillan and Sarah McMillan - King Of My Heart

Guy Penrod Guy Penrod - Then Came the Morning (Live)
Blog
At GodTube, you’ll find daily inspirational videos to lift your spirits and encourage you in your walk with God. Popular videos include worship music from your favorite Christian artists, cute videos with adorable kids and animals, hilarious videos from Christian comedians, user-uploaded videos, and clean viral videos to brighten your day.









